This third in the “Daughter of Sherlock Holmes” series was my introduction to Joanna Blalock Watson and her small family, born sleuths, all of them. Joanna is the flesh and blood daughter of the famous detective, and her father-in-law is the ever-present Dr. Watson. Her husband, Watson’s son, narrates, and her son Johnny promises to be his grandfather Sherlock all over again. It’s World War I, so, as you’d expect, there are German spies, zeppelins and U-boats, encryption and experts, clandestine affairs (or not?), and a dastardly traitor. Who? (I figured it out; I figured it out!) There’s even a fake funeral involving a long-dead cat. Nice touch.
All this gives Joanna ample opportunity to dazzle with that famous deductive reasoning, but, in the Holmes tradition, there can be no rush to judgment. She moves at a measured pace, dispensing conclusions in small, intriguing doses, and, like her father, is more than a bit condescending to those of lesser gifts……and isn’t that everybody? While it may be something of a trudge for the modern reader, if you’re a Conan Doyle fan and don’t want to re-read him for the umpteenth time, this is well-done and as close as you can get. Prefer your detective series in order? Begin with The Daughter of Sherlock Holmes and follow with A Study in Treason. This installment makes its appearance on June 11 from Minotaur Books.
Full Disclosure: A review copy of this book was provided to me by St. Martin’s Press / Minotaur Books via NetGalley. I would like to thank the publisher and the author for providing me this opportunity. All opinions expressed herein are my own.